Difficult Productively Group Puzzle
Permission is granted to teachers in grades K-12 to print and photocopy these puzzles for use in their classes. Permission is also granted for parents and individuals to print for educational and personal developement. Please share this link with friends on social media and email so they can practice as well.

Place each element of the group (P R O D U C T I V E L Y) exactly once in each row, each column, each 4x3 rectangle, each eye, and the elements that make up the smile.

Deductive steps to solve the puzzle

The moves within each step may be done in any order.

All of the moves within a particular step must be done before all of the moves in the subsequent step can be guaranteed to be completed.

Rows are numbered top to bottom, columns from left to right, and rectangles from left to right and then top to bottom. Coordinates are (col, row). Precise details on numbering within each group are specified in the on-line instructions .

Step 1. There are 12 independent moves.

• The only spot left for P in the 10th row is at (2, 10).
• The only spot left for D in the 12th row is at (3, 12).
• The only spot left for L in the 4th column is at (4, 12).
• The only spot left for P in the 4th column is at (4, 4).
• The only spot left for L in the 8th column is at (8, 2).
• The only spot left for O in the 7th 4x3 rectangle is at (1, 9).
• The only spot left for I in the 8th 4x3 rectangle is at (6, 7).
• The only spot left for L in the 11th 4x3 rectangle is at (7, 11).
• The only spot left for P in the 12th 4x3 rectangle is at (12, 11).
• The only spot left for Y in the 2nd eye is at (11, 5).
• The only spot left for E in the elements that make up the smile is at (7, 12).
• The only spot left for T in the elements that make up the smile is at (5, 11).

Step 2. There are 9 independent moves.

• The only spot left for P in the 9th row is at (9, 9).
• The only spot left for Y in the 3rd column is at (3, 3).
• The only spot left for L in the 1st 4x3 rectangle is at (1, 3).
• The only spot left for D in the 4th 4x3 rectangle is at (2, 6).
• The only spot left for Y in the 4th 4x3 rectangle is at (1, 4).
• The only spot left for P in the 7th 4x3 rectangle is at (3, 7).
• The only spot left for Y in the 11th 4x3 rectangle is at (7, 10).
• The only spot left for P in the 1st eye is at (5, 5).
• The only spot left for Y in the elements that make up the smile is at (10, 9).

Step 3. There are 11 independent moves.

• The only spot left for L in the 7th row is at (12, 7).
• The only spot left for E in the 1st 4x3 rectangle is at (2, 3).
• The only spot left for T in the 1st 4x3 rectangle is at (1, 2).
• The only spot left for P in the 2nd 4x3 rectangle is at (7, 2).
• The only spot left for Y in the 2nd 4x3 rectangle is at (5, 2).
• The only spot left for V in the 4th 4x3 rectangle is at (4, 6).
• The only spot left for L in the 7th 4x3 rectangle is at (3, 8).
• The only spot left for Y in the 10th 4x3 rectangle is at (2, 11).
• The only spot left for Y in the 12th 4x3 rectangle is at (9, 12).
• The only spot left for T in the 1st eye is at (3, 5).
• The only spot left for R in the elements that make up the smile is at (3, 9).

Step 4. There are 8 independent moves.

• The only spot left for D in the 2nd row is at (11, 2).
• The only spot left for R in the 7th row is at (7, 7).
• The only spot left for U in the 1st column is at (1, 10).
• The only spot left for E in the 5th column is at (5, 8).
• The only spot left for V in the 1st 4x3 rectangle is at (2, 2).
• The only spot left for I in the 4th 4x3 rectangle is at (3, 6).
• The only spot left for T in the 5th 4x3 rectangle is at (6, 4).
• The only spot left for V in the 1st eye is at (5, 3).

Step 5. There are 6 independent moves.

• The only spot left for C in the 5th column is at (5, 9).
• The only spot left for E in the 11th column is at (11, 7).
• The only spot left for R in the 2nd 4x3 rectangle is at (6, 3).
• The only spot left for R in the 5th 4x3 rectangle is at (8, 6).
• The only spot left for D in the 1st eye is at (5, 4).
• The only spot left for U in the elements that make up the smile is at (8, 11).

Step 6. There are 7 independent moves.

• The only spot left for D in the 6th column is at (6, 10).
• The only spot left for U in the 6th column is at (6, 5).
• The only spot left for V in the 8th column is at (8, 8).
• The only spot left for D in the 8th 4x3 rectangle is at (7, 9).
• The only spot left for C in the 11th 4x3 rectangle is at (8, 10).
• The only spot left for D in the 2nd eye is at (8, 3).
• The only spot left for V in the elements that make up the smile is at (6, 12).

Step 7. There are 8 independent moves.

• The only spot left for U in the 9th row is at (2, 9).
• The only spot left for O in the 8th column is at (8, 4).
• The only spot left for O in the 2nd 4x3 rectangle is at (7, 3).
• The only spot left for V in the 5th 4x3 rectangle is at (7, 5).
• The only spot left for U in the 8th 4x3 rectangle is at (7, 8).
• The only spot left for O in the 11th 4x3 rectangle is at (6, 11).
• The only spot left for V in the 12th 4x3 rectangle is at (10, 11).
• The only spot left for C in the elements that make up the smile is at (4, 11).

Step 8. There are 9 independent moves.

• The only spot left for E in the 4th row is at (9, 4).
• The only spot left for C in the 5th row is at (1, 5).
• The only spot left for I in the 9th row is at (11, 9).
• The only spot left for O in the 3rd 4x3 rectangle is at (12, 2).
• The only spot left for C in the 5th 4x3 rectangle is at (7, 6).
• The only spot left for I in the 7th 4x3 rectangle is at (2, 8).
• The only spot left for U in the 9th 4x3 rectangle is at (9, 7).
• The only spot left for E in the 2nd eye is at (8, 5).
• The only spot left for O in the elements that make up the smile is at (4, 10).

Step 9. There are 8 independent moves.

• The only spot left for I in the 2nd row is at (4, 2).
• The only spot left for O in the 11th column is at (11, 8).
• The only spot left for I in the 3rd 4x3 rectangle is at (12, 3).
• The only spot left for E in the 4th 4x3 rectangle is at (1, 6).
• The only spot left for C in the 7th 4x3 rectangle is at (2, 7).
• The only spot left for O in the 12th 4x3 rectangle is at (10, 12).
• The only spot left for I in the 12th 4x3 rectangle is at (10, 10).
• The only spot left for U in the 2nd eye is at (10, 2).

Step 10. There are 6 independent moves.

• The only spot left for C in the 11th column is at (11, 3).
• The only spot left for U in the 6th 4x3 rectangle is at (12, 6).
• The only spot left for O in the 6th 4x3 rectangle is at (9, 6).
• The only spot left for C in the 12th 4x3 rectangle is at (12, 12).
• The only spot left for T in the 12th 4x3 rectangle is at (11, 10).
• The only spot left for U in the 1st eye is at (4, 3).

Step 11. There are 5 independent moves.

• The only spot left for C in the 9th column is at (9, 8).
• The only spot left for T in the 12th column is at (12, 8).
• The only spot left for T in the 6th 4x3 rectangle is at (10, 6).
• The only spot left for C in the 6th 4x3 rectangle is at (10, 4).
• The only spot left for T in the 2nd eye is at (9, 3).

Step 12. There are 2 independent moves.

• The only spot left for R in the 6th 4x3 rectangle is at (12, 4).
• The only spot left for R in the 9th 4x3 rectangle is at (10, 8).

  https://www.grouppuzzles.com